Medical malpractice

Why a Florida Medical Malpractice Claim Requires a Medical Expert Before Filing

Direct answer

Yes. Florida law requires your attorney to obtain a written opinion from a qualified medical expert confirming there are reasonable grounds to believe malpractice occurred before a notice of intent to sue can even be served on the defendant. Without that corroborating expert opinion in hand, the claim cannot move forward, courts will dismiss cases that skip this step. This requirement adds time and cost to the process, so understanding it early protects your ability to meet Florida's filing deadlines.

Why a Florida Medical Malpractice Claim Requires a Medical Expert Before Filing

What is the short answer: can I just file a malpractice lawsuit in Florida?

No. A Florida medical malpractice claim cannot be filed the way a car accident or slip-and-fall lawsuit can. Under Chapter 766 of the Florida Statutes, a mandatory presuit investigation process stands between you and the courthouse, and every step in that process is required by law.

If you were rear-ended on the Palmetto Expressway, your attorney can file suit directly, subject only to the statute of limitations. A malpractice claimant does not have that option. Before any lawsuit is filed, Florida law requires a formal investigation, a written opinion from a qualified medical expert, and service of a notice of intent on every prospective defendant. Skipping any step exposes your case to dismissal and can expose your attorney to sanctions. This is not a procedural technicality. It is the law, and courts enforce it strictly.

What is the presuit investigation and why does it require a corroborating expert opinion?

Before your attorney can even serve the notice of intent, Florida law requires a reasonable investigation of your claim. That means obtaining your complete medical records, having a qualified medical expert review them, and securing a verified written opinion from that expert stating there are reasonable grounds to believe the defendant was negligent and that the negligence caused your injury. The requirement comes from Fla. Stat. § 766.203, read together with § 766.104.

A bad outcome alone is not malpractice. Surgery carries inherent risks, and patients can deteriorate for reasons that have nothing to do with a provider’s conduct. The standard of care under § 766.102 is what a reasonably prudent similar provider would do under similar circumstances. The expert’s written opinion must identify the specific departure from that standard and give the defendant enough information to evaluate the claim.

The precision of that opinion matters, because a defendant may challenge a claim that the expert opinion does not support.

Who can serve as the corroborating medical expert?

The expert must generally practice, or have practiced, in the same specialty as the defendant provider. Under Fla. Stat. § 766.102, the expert must also have been engaged in clinical practice or instruction in that specialty during a qualifying period before the alleged negligence occurred. A generalist cannot corroborate a subspecialty claim.

Courts apply this rule strictly, and a corroborating opinion from a physician in a different specialty can put the claim at risk.

Finding a willing, qualified physician takes time, sometimes weeks, sometimes months. Expert review and opinion drafting also involve significant cost that you should understand before the case moves forward. Defense counsel will review the expert’s credentials, clinical history, and litigation background carefully, so the quality of the opinion and the standing of the person who signs it matter as much as the content. A credentialed, active clinician who can withstand that scrutiny is harder to find and more valuable to your case than one who merely holds the right license.

What happens after the expert opinion is ready: what is the notice of intent and the 90-day period?

Once the corroborating expert opinion is secured, your attorney serves a notice of intent to initiate medical malpractice litigation on each prospective defendant. Under Fla. Stat. § 766.106, the notice must be accompanied by the verified written medical expert opinion.

Service of the notice triggers a 90-day presuit screening period. During those 90 days, no lawsuit may be filed. Both sides may conduct limited informal discovery under Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.650: such as document requests, written questions, unsworn statements of treating providers, and physical examinations.

The defendant must respond during the presuit period by admitting liability, rejecting the claim, or making a settlement offer. If the defendant serves a written rejection before the 90 days expire, you may file suit sooner. The statute of limitations is tolled during this period, meaning the clock pauses while presuit screening runs. After the presuit period closes, you have a defined window to file suit or risk being time-barred.

What does all of this mean for my timeline and costs?

A Florida medical malpractice case requires substantial preparation before a complaint is ever filed. The investigation, records collection, expert identification, expert review, and opinion drafting typically take months. The 90-day presuit period follows. Only then can a lawsuit be filed.

Under Fla. Stat. § 95.11, the statute of limitations for a medical malpractice claim is generally two years from the incident or from when the injury was discovered or reasonably should have been discovered, and generally no more than four years from the incident (longer only in limited cases such as fraud or concealment, and special rules for young children). The tolling provision under § 766.106 pauses the clock during the presuit notice period. It does not pause the clock during the investigation phase that must be completed before the notice is even served.

That distinction matters. If you wait months before contacting an attorney, you may not have enough time left to complete a proper investigation, locate a qualified expert, and obtain a written opinion before the presuit notice needs to go out. Every week spent waiting is a week that cannot be recovered. Expert fees represent a real and significant upfront cost in these cases, and you should understand that before deciding how to proceed. A free consultation is the right place to get those questions answered. At Wolfson & Leon, there is no fee unless we win.

For more background on what this process looks like in practice, see our overview of what counts as medical malpractice in Florida, the questions to ask a medical malpractice lawyer before hiring, and what the Florida presuit process requires before suing a hospital.

Frequently asked questions

What happens if my attorney files a malpractice lawsuit without getting the expert opinion first?

The court can dismiss the case. Florida courts treat the verified corroborating expert opinion as a mandatory prerequisite, not a technicality that can be cured after the fact. Filing without it also exposes the attorney to sanctions under Chapter 766.

Does the medical expert have to be a Florida doctor?

Not necessarily, but Florida has additional requirements for experts who are not licensed in Florida. The core requirement under § 766.102 is that the expert be licensed in medicine or osteopathic medicine and have practiced or taught in the same specialty as the defendant during the qualifying period. Your attorney will confirm that any out-of-state expert qualifies under Florida law.

Does the 90-day presuit period stop my statute of limitations from running?

Yes, but only during the presuit notice period itself. Under § 766.106, the statute of limitations is tolled once the notice of intent is served. The investigation phase that comes before the notice is not tolled, so delays in starting the investigation still consume time from your two-year window.

Is a bad outcome from surgery or treatment automatically malpractice in Florida?

No. Medicine carries inherent risks, and patients can have serious complications or deteriorate for reasons unrelated to anything a provider did wrong. Malpractice requires showing that the provider departed from the standard of care that a reasonably prudent similar provider would have met, and that the departure caused the patient’s injury. A qualified medical expert must be able to say that in writing before your case can proceed.

Can the defendant use the presuit period to gather information against my claim?

Yes. Presuit discovery under Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.650 runs in both directions. The defendant can request documents, submit written questions, and arrange a physical examination of the claimant. Information gathered during that period can inform the defendant’s decision to reject, settle, or admit the claim, and can shape defense strategy if the case moves into litigation.

Complete guide: Medical Malpractice in Florida: The Complete Guide for Hialeah Patients

Hurt in an accident in Hialeah? Call Wolfson & Leon at 305-965-3766 for a free consultation. We speak Spanish, and there is no fee unless we win.

Key facts

  • Florida Statute § 766.203 requires a verified written medical expert opinion corroborating reasonable grounds for the malpractice claim before the presuit notice of intent is served. Source: Fla. Stat. § 766.203
  • Florida Statute § 766.106 requires the claimant to serve a notice of intent to initiate medical negligence litigation on each prospective defendant, triggering a 90-day presuit screening period during which no lawsuit may be filed. Source: Fla. Stat. § 766.106
  • The corroborating medical expert must generally be licensed and, where applicable, board-certified in the same specialty as the defendant provider, and must have been engaged in clinical practice or instruction in that specialty during a qualifying period preceding the alleged negligence. Source: Fla. Stat. § 766.102
  • The statute of limitations for a Florida medical malpractice claim is generally two years from the incident or from when the injury was discovered or reasonably should have been discovered, and generally no more than four years from the incident, with longer periods only in limited cases such as fraud or concealment. Source: Fla. Stat. § 95.11
  • The statute of limitations is tolled, meaning the clock pauses, during the presuit period triggered by service of the notice of intent. Source: Fla. Stat. § 766.106

Frequently asked questions

What happens if my attorney files a malpractice lawsuit without getting the expert opinion first?

Florida courts treat the corroborating expert opinion as a mandatory prerequisite, not a technicality. A lawsuit filed without completing the required presuit investigation and obtaining the verified expert opinion can be dismissed. Both the claimant and the attorney may face sanctions. Florida Statute § 766.104 and § 766.203 make clear that the investigation and expert corroboration must happen before the notice of intent is served, not after the lawsuit is filed.

Does the medical expert have to be a Florida doctor?

An out-of-state physician may be able to serve as the corroborating expert, but Florida has additional requirements for experts not licensed in Florida, and the expert must meet the qualification requirements set out in Florida Statute § 766.102. That generally means the expert must be licensed in their state, must practice or have practiced in the same specialty as the defendant provider, and must have been engaged in clinical practice or instruction in that specialty during the qualifying period before the alleged negligence. The same-specialty requirement is strictly enforced.

Does the 90-day presuit period stop my statute of limitations from running?

Yes, but only once the notice of intent has been served. Florida Statute § 766.106 tolls the statute of limitations during the presuit screening period. However, the investigation phase, gathering records, finding an expert, and obtaining the written opinion, happens before the notice is served and is not tolled. Because that pre-notice work can take months, waiting to start the process eats into the time you have before the limitations period expires.

Is a bad outcome from surgery or treatment automatically malpractice in Florida?

No. Florida law recognizes that medicine carries inherent risks and that patients can deteriorate for reasons unrelated to a provider's conduct. To establish malpractice, the evidence must show that the provider's care fell below the standard that a reasonably prudent similar provider would have used under the same circumstances, and that this failure caused the patient's injury. A qualified medical expert's opinion is required to establish both the breach and causation, a bad result alone is not enough.

Can the defendant use the presuit period to gather information against my claim?

Yes. During the 90-day presuit screening period, Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.650 allows both sides to conduct limited informal discovery. The defendant may request medical records, submit written questions, and require the claimant to undergo a physical examination. The defendant may also take unsworn statements from the claimant's treating healthcare providers. Statements and examination findings obtained during this period are generally limited to presuit screening purposes and are not directly admissible in later civil proceedings.

This article is general information about Florida law, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. For advice about your situation, call Wolfson & Leon at 305-965-3766 for a free consultation.

Also available in: Versión en español

More on this topic

Free consultation · Se habla español

Talk to a Hialeah injury lawyer today

The consultation is free and confidential. Call, or tell us what happened and we call you back. English or Spanish.